How to Choose a Precious Metals IRA Company

Affiliate disclosure: White Metal Resources may earn a commission when you open an account through links on this page. This never changes what you pay or what we write. We are not financial or tax advisors. Consult a licensed advisor before making retirement decisions.

Last updated: July 23, 2026 · By White Metal Resources Editorial

This page is the picking framework the rest of White Metal Resources uses. Every company review on the site sends its "how we picked" card here, so the criteria are stated once, in one place, in the order a saver actually needs them. Each check ties back to a specific fact a firm must put in writing.

The five criteria, in decision order

Fifty precious metals IRA firms compete for the same rollover dollar, and marketing pages differ more than the underlying accounts do. The account structure is standardized: a self-directed IRA custodian holds legal title, an IRS-approved depository holds the physical metal, and a dealer sells you the coins or bars. What varies is the paperwork you get before you fund, and the honesty of the intake call.

Below is the check order that saves you the most time. Fail one, drop the firm. There is no need to reach criterion five if a candidate refuses criterion one on the phone.

Criteria synthesized from IRC 408(m); IRS Investments-in-Collectibles Issue Snapshot; BBB dealer profiles; CFTC precious metals enforcement history. Checked July 2026.

The rest of this page explains each criterion, the paperwork it demands, and the specific line to ask a specialist on the intake call.

Criterion 1: fee transparency in dollars

Fees are where a strong firm and a weak firm diverge the most, and where a saver loses or keeps the most compound growth over ten years. Five lines cover every fee a precious metals IRA carries, and a top firm quotes each in dollars before you commit.

Ask, in this order, for a written schedule that answers each item:

1. Account setup fee. The one-time fee paid to the custodian at account opening, usually between $50 and $100 across the sector.
2. Annual custodian fee. The recurring administration fee, usually between $75 and $300 a year.
3. Annual depository storage fee. Usually between $100 and $300 a year for common bullion. Segregated storage costs more than commingled.
4. Dealer markup on the initial purchase. Quoted as a percentage of your order or a specific dollars-per-coin figure on the coins you plan to buy.
5. Dealer spread at buyback. Or the current buyback policy in writing, ideally with a sample bid on the coins you plan to hold.

The calculator below estimates how fixed annual fees compound against an account over time. Enter a balance and a fee rate to see the drag on a longer horizon.

Only one of the four larger firms we reviewed prints a specific fee range in dollars on its own gold IRA product page. Augusta Precious Metals lists custodian fees at 75 to 150 dollars a year and storage at 100 to 150 dollars a year (source: augustapreciousmetals.com, checked July 2026). The other three quote fees on request rather than in prose. That is not disqualifying, but you need the schedule in writing before you send funds.

The single largest lifetime cost of a precious metals IRA is the dealer markup on the initial coin or bar order, not the annual fees. On common .995 bars or American Gold Eagles for larger orders it usually sits in the low single digits over spot. On proof or graded premium coins it can pass 20 percent of the order. See our gold IRA fees anatomy for the full breakdown.

Flat annual fees hurt small balances hardest. A fixed $300 a year is 3 percent on a $10,000 account and 0.30 percent on a $100,000 account. The right minimum for the firm and the right balance for your fee load are the same question, from opposite ends.

Criterion 2: named custodian and depository

A precious metals IRA has three parties, not one. The dealer sells you the metal, a self-directed IRA custodian holds legal title to the account, and an IRS-approved depository takes physical possession of the metal. A top firm names its custodian and its depository up front, on the same document as its fee schedule.

Federal law under IRC 408(m)(3) requires the metal to sit "in the physical possession of a trustee described under subsection (a)," which means a bank or an IRS-approved non-bank trustee (source: 26 U.S.C. Section 408(m)). Home storage of IRA metal is a taxable distribution. The U.S. Tax Court applied that rule against the taxpayers in McNulty v. Commissioner, 157 T.C. 10 in 2021.

Common depositories that surface across dealer disclosures include Delaware Depository in Wilmington, International Depository Services in New Castle and Dallas, and Brink's Global Services with vaults in New York, Salt Lake City, and Los Angeles. The custodian side is less standardized. A firm that answers "our qualified custodian" without naming it before you fund is asking you to sign on faith.

Two questions settle this criterion on a single call:

• Which self-directed IRA custodian will hold my account, and what is the URL of its regulator disclosure page?
• Which IRS-approved depository will hold my metal, at which vault location, and is storage segregated or commingled?

If either answer requires a callback, the firm is not ready for a rollover.

Criterion 3: white metals product depth at the correct fineness

Every legitimate precious metals IRA firm follows the same IRS purity rules. If a dealer offers metal below those minimums, it is not IRA-eligible regardless of what the marketing says.

The recognized minimums are silver .999, gold .995, and platinum or palladium .9995. Those numbers come from commodity-market delivery standards referenced by IRC 408(m)(3)(B), not from a literal figure in the tax code (source: 26 U.S.C. Section 408(m)).

American Silver, Gold, and Platinum Eagles qualify separately under the 31 USC 5112 carve-out for United States coins. That is how the American Gold Eagle at 22 karat (.9167) sits inside an IRA even though it fails the bar standard (source: IRS collectibles snapshot).

For a white metals saver, product depth matters as much as purity. Silver is a first-class product at Goldco and Noble Gold Investments, each with a dedicated Silver IRA landing page and a published minimum on the product page itself (source: goldco.com, noblegoldinvestments.com, checked July 2026). Platinum and palladium IRAs are a smaller niche across the sector; even at the larger dealers, dedicated landing pages are the exception rather than the rule.

Ask a candidate two questions:

• Show me the specific coins and bars you sell in each metal, with fineness printed on the same product line, and confirm each is IRA-eligible under IRC 408(m) or the 31 USC 5112 carve-out.
• Which of these are premium coins, and what is the markup over spot on each, in writing?

Rhodium and iridium are not on the statutory list and never qualify at any fineness. Bars must come from a refiner that meets the delivery standard. The London Bullion Market Association sets the Good Delivery standard for gold and silver bars (source: LBMA Good Delivery).

Criterion 4: complaint record and years in business

Two independent facts anchor a firm's reputation. First, its Better Business Bureau profile, which shows the letter rating, the accreditation date, and the closed-complaint volume. Second, its dateable operating history, which you can cross-check against a state LLC filing or an archived version of the site.

The Better Business Bureau profile is a starting point, not a verdict. An A+ rating with 3 complaints in 3 years reads very differently from an A+ rating with 90 complaints in 3 years. Read the complaint pattern before the letter. A recurring theme, whether it is late shipments, unrequested premium coin substitutions, or buyback disputes, is more informative than the aggregate score.

Years in business helps you distinguish a stable operator from a rebrand. Firms that pass this criterion cleanly include Augusta Precious Metals, trading under its current name since 2012, and Noble Gold Investments, active since 2003 (source: augustapreciousmetals.com, noblegoldinvestments.com, checked July 2026). A firm without a dateable history is not automatically disqualifying, but it moves the burden of proof.

Federal regulators police the underlying metals markets even when they do not police individual dealers. In 2020 the Commodity Futures Trading Commission required JPMorgan Chase to pay $920.2 million in a spoofing order across gold, silver, platinum, and palladium futures (source: CFTC release 8260-20). That is a reminder the metals market has enforcement history. A firm that publishes verifiable facts about itself is easier to defend against that backdrop.

Criterion 5: pressure tactics and the sales approach

The intake call reveals more than any product page. A specialist who runs an education-first process asks about your situation, answers your questions in plain language, and lets you leave without a commitment. A specialist who runs a pressure-close process pushes for a same-day signature, adds urgency framing to the price of the metal, and dangles a bonus that only unlocks on a premium coin order.

The most common trap is the free silver promotion. A saver is offered thousands of dollars in "free silver" if the initial coin order clears a threshold. The threshold is usually a premium or proof coin line rather than common bullion. The bonus is real, but the markup on those premium coins usually exceeds it. Those coins may or may not sit cleanly inside IRC 408(m). The Federal Trade Commission has cautioned savers on this pattern.

Three specific tests during the intake call:

• Ask for the fee schedule in writing to the email address on file, and end the call. A firm that agrees without friction passes. A firm that pushes for a same-day close fails.
• Ask for the recommended coin mix and the markup over spot on each coin. Take note of any pivot from common bullion toward proof, graded, or "exclusive" coins.
• Ask what happens if you decide to walk away after the fee document arrives. The answer sets the tone of the entire relationship.

Salaried non-commissioned specialists exist across the sector, notably at Augusta Precious Metals, whose public positioning describes the sales team as "salaried, non-commissioned educators" and frames the process as "Education-First: Learn-Talk-Decide" (source: augustapreciousmetals.com, checked July 2026). The compensation model is not the whole picture, but it aligns the incentive with information rather than pressure.

The framework applied to specific dealers

The five criteria are the same for every dealer we review. What differs is how much each firm publishes on its own site. The table below applies the framework to four dealers that are large enough to compare fairly and that publish enough facts on their own pages.

Sources: augustapreciousmetals.com, goldco.com, noblegoldinvestments.com, americanhartfordgold.com. Checked July 2026. BBB status displayed by the dealer; verify the current rating on the Better Business Bureau profile before you commit.

Neutral notes. Augusta is a partner of White Metal Resources. The numbers above come from Augusta's own public gold IRA page. Goldco, Noble Gold Investments, and American Hartford Gold are linked here as examples of the framework in action, not as endorsements.

For a full breakdown of each, see the Goldco review, the Noble Gold Investments review, and the American Hartford Gold review. The Augusta Precious Metals review covers the partner in full, with the same criteria applied.

Two smaller firms illustrate how the criteria act as a filter. The Lear Capital review and the American Bullion review both walk through fee disclosure, custodian naming, and complaint history for firms outside the top-of-mind marketing lists.

Worked example: two firms compared on a $75,000 rollover

When a specialist dealer is the wrong tool

A specialist precious metals IRA dealer is a fit for a specific kind of saver. It is the wrong tool for several others, and saying so plainly is part of an honest picking framework. There is no CTA in this section on purpose.

• You need broad diversification with low frictional costs. A precious metals IRA carries a setup fee, an annual custodian fee, an annual storage fee, and a dealer spread on every metal purchase. A gold or silver exchange-traded fund inside a mainstream brokerage IRA delivers metal price exposure at a fraction of the annual cost, even though it does not deliver physical metal.
• You are under 59.5 and may need the money within a few years. An early distribution triggers ordinary income tax plus a 10 percent federal additional tax under IRC Section 72(t). Selling metal on that timeline also means crossing the dealer spread twice, which is a mechanical loss on top of the tax hit.
• Your balance is small enough that flat fees dominate. A fixed $300 in annual custodian and storage fees is 3 percent on a $10,000 account. Compound drag at that level is difficult to recover, and the metal has to move a long way to break even.
• Your priority is platinum or palladium in an IRA. None of the larger firms runs a dedicated Platinum IRA or Palladium IRA landing page, so a specialist call with product-specific questions matters more than the marketing gloss. A saver who wants a deep platinum portfolio may find it faster to buy physical outside an IRA.
• You are shopping for a specific numismatic collection. Numismatic and graded rare coins are treated as collectibles under IRC 408(m), which triggers a deemed distribution at cost the day they enter the IRA. A specialist IRA dealer is the wrong tool for that collection, regardless of how attractive the coins look.

If one of these describes you, slowing down is the sensible call. The framework above still helps you cross-check whichever route you choose next.

How to choose a precious metals IRA company: questions, answered

What is the most important criterion when choosing a precious metals IRA company?

Fee transparency in dollars, before you fund. Setup fee, annual custodian fee, annual storage fee, and the dealer spread on the specific coins or bars you plan to buy, all in writing. A firm that will not put every line in dollars is telling you something worth listening to, and no other criterion matters if the first one fails.

How do I check the fees of a precious metals IRA company?

Ask the intake specialist to email you the full fee schedule before your next call. Setup, annual custodian, annual storage, dealer markup on each coin or bar, and buyback policy. Cross-check what arrives against any dollar figure printed on the firm's own product page. Augusta Precious Metals is one of the few firms that prints a specific custodian and storage fee range on its gold IRA page (source: augustapreciousmetals.com, checked July 2026).

How do I verify a precious metals IRA custodian and depository?

Ask the dealer to name both in writing, then look each one up. The custodian must be a bank or an IRS-approved non-bank trustee. The depository must be IRS-approved and takes physical possession of the metal, because home storage is a taxable distribution under IRC 408(m). Delaware Depository, International Depository Services, and Brink's Global Services surface commonly across dealer disclosures.

Do I really need a firm that offers all four metals?

Not necessarily. A gold-and-silver-only firm can still be excellent if the two metals cover your goals. What you need is written proof that each metal you actually plan to hold is available at the statutory fineness: silver .999, gold .995, platinum and palladium .9995. If your priority is platinum or palladium, ask for product-level details on the intake call, because dedicated landing pages for those metals are rare.

How do I read a BBB profile for a precious metals IRA company?

Open the profile at bbb.org and read the complaint volume before you read the letter rating. Look at how many complaints closed in the last 3 years and, more importantly, the pattern. A recurring complaint type, whether it is unrequested coin substitutions, late shipments, or buyback disputes, tells you more than the aggregate letter. Accreditation and the accreditation date are useful, but a shiny letter without pattern context is not a verdict.

What sales tactics should disqualify a precious metals IRA dealer?

Any pressure toward a same-day close, urgency framing tied to the price of the metal, and free silver bonuses that only unlock on premium or proof coin orders. Those bonuses are the classic upsell trap: the markup baked into the premium coins usually exceeds the value of the free silver, and premium coins may not sit cleanly inside IRC 408(m). Salaried non-commissioned specialists reduce that pressure by design.

Can a precious metals IRA company change my custodian later without asking me?

No. You direct the account. The dealer coordinates with the self-directed IRA custodian, but the custodian is a party to the account and cannot be swapped without your paperwork. Ask the intake specialist what happens if the dealer's preferred custodian changes providers, and confirm the answer in writing. A firm that treats the custodian as interchangeable is one to check twice.

Is it enough to pick the highest-rated precious metals IRA company on a “best of” list?

No. Published "best of" lists are editorial choices, and many are paid affiliate placements. Use them as a starting shortlist, then apply the five criteria above to each firm on your own. A firm that clears fees, custodian, depository, product depth, and pressure tactics deserves your rollover regardless of where it sits on someone else's ranking.